
This was an interesting juxtaposition of two very different wines, both comprised of 100% Shiraz from the same vineyards in the Ebeneezer District of the northern Barossa Valley. Similar vinification practices were used, and both wines spent about twelve months in American oak hogsheads before bottling - so this is a study in pure vintage variation.
The Riebke 2005
This wine is a deep, inky purple with a garnet edge. The nose offers aromas of dark plums, blackberries, and cassis, with tar, sweet oak, and Rhone-ish notes of bacon fat, garrigue, and graphite. It is soft and supple in the mouth, medium-bodied, with pure fruit, sweet tannins, and present acidity. This is a well balanced Shiraz that matches the ripe fruit flavors of blackberry, cherry, and plum, with interesting notes of roast/smoky meats, herbs, earth, and minerals. Plenty of toasty vanilla oak is in the mix as well, but doesn't dominate. The wine is layered through a very nice finish of pure fruit, oak, and gentle tannic grip. A very urbane expression of Barossa Shiraz that pays tribute to the grape's Rhone origins - and an great value at $14.99! Unlike many Aussies, this one is refined enough to pair with roast meat dishes and hard cheeses, etc.
The Riebke 2006
Teusner went from urbane in '05 to "octane" in '06, as the 2006 Riebke is a rip-roaring, full-throttle Barossa Shiraz of the first order! The wine is also a deep, inky purple in the glass. Intense, almost forceful aromas of cherry liquer and blueberry pie erupt from the glass, heavily accented by scorched earth, graphite, oak toast, and faint spices. On the palate this wine is just as brash - full-bodied, plush, jammy, and huge. But I should point out that it maintains serious structure in the form of solid acidity and fine, supple tannins. This is no simple fruit bomb, it is an opulent and intense expression of high-end Aussie Shiraz, with no significant Rhone-ish trappings. Flavors in the mouth are consistent with the nose, gobs of kirsch, blueberry pie, blackberry and plum fruit, with glycerin, scorched earth, tar, white pepper, pain grille, and a hint of eucalyptus. The finish is long and mouth-staining, with plenty of toasty oak and sweet fruit that clings to the cheeks for a long, long time.
This is not a Shiraz for the faint of heart - we actually exclaimed profanities several times while drinking it. It is an apt description - this is a @#$%#$ of a Shiraz!
If you are looking for straight-down-the-middle, hedonistic Barossa fare, it would be hard to beat this wine at any price point. Its no Grange, but at $16.99, it is an absolute steal.
This wine would overpower most foods, except for grilled meats and strong cheeses like dry jack or a bandaged cheddar.